Sidram Narsayya Chilka, V. ACIT Cir 2,

CO 29/PUN/2006

• Counselvise Citation: [2010] 122 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 5440 (ITAT-PUNE)
• Duration Of Justice: 4 year(s) 1 month(s) 14 day(s)
• Appeal Type: Cross Objection
• Pronouncement Date: 24-11-2010
• Appeal Filed By: Assessee
• Order Result: Dismissed
• Bench Allotted: Not Allotted
• Assessment Year: misc
• Appeal Filed On: 10-10-2006
• Result in Favour of: Revenue
• Court: TRIBUNAL

Judgement Text

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Ǎ% -4'6:?027;6(020&%2;'-72%0Ǎ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