Appeal Details
Counselvise Citation
[2010] 135 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 3176 (ITAT-PUNE)
Assessee PAN
Bench
Appeal Number
CRN Number
Duration Of Justice
5 year(s) 7 month(s) 9 day(s)
Appellant
Respondent
Appeal Type
Income Tax Appeal
Pronouncement Date
24-11-2010
Appeal Filed By
Assessee
Order Result
Allowed
Bench Allotted
Not Allotted
Assessment Year
misc
Appeal Filed On
15-04-2005
Judgement Text
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
Other Referred Cases
-
Laws Referred To
-
1:1 Consultation on Startup Fundraising
₹5000
1:1 Consultation with family dentist -Your Smile Deserves the Best Care!
₹250
1:1 Consultation on Business Development
₹1
Memorandum Amendment Resolution
₹0
Social Media Brand Kit
₹100
Why Lacoste Won a 20-Year Trademark Battle Against Crocodile ?
Team Counselvise - March 10, 2026
Finance Bill, 2026: Key GST Reforms that will Reshape Compliance and Cash Flows
Team Counselvise - February 03, 2026
SEBI Resets Mutual Fund Rules: A Structural Shift for Investors
Team Counselvise - March 13, 2026