, , .. , .., . . . 287/ / 2016 + + : 2008009 . 2 4+ + 5. , 9 , ; 2(1), > 5;> . . .: 6934 > C : D , 5;> C : G , D 5I I : 1 9 . 0 9 . 2016 K I : 19 . 0 9 . 2016 .. , M + + 2008009 +N M D M 9 ()0II, I,1961 C 14 7/143(3) N P 30.11.2015 DRK S T U+ S U C 2. 5 XY Z [ \ DM 9 () 5 0 S C . . . 287 / / 2016 . 2 4+ + 5. ., 2 +N C T U \ U \ \ 9 () 5 DM 9 () ` C A +N C N C 3. C , DM 5I 5I \ , D \ , DM D 5I 9 () + 4. S S A \ \ C T +N , +N C T + \ (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) K 5 C (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) + \ \ G9 P P K 5; ,. (SINE QUA NON) P , 5 I 5 , 5 I , 5 , DI 5 I; , I 5, C N+ P + + + \ JK M (1978 597; 1 248) 5 T + \ , T JK N \ \ N I O \ C (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) 5 +0 + \ + 5 T, +N I P , \ +N 5 5 P P , +N C 5Y DM 9 () 5 Z P DM . . . 287 / / 2016 . 2 4+ + 5. ., 3 9 () +N I O DI + P 6. N, +N C {C |OS C 19.09.2016 T MD \ /0 /0 (..) (.. ) P : 19.09. 2016 5 D : > , 5;> , 9 () , 9 , D 5I , +