SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, Bhopal V. THE CIT-I, Bhopal

ITA 318/IND/2015

• Counselvise Citation: [2020] 111 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 8466 (ITAT-INDORE)
• Duration Of Justice: 4 year(s) 8 month(s) 5 day(s)
• Appeal Type: Income Tax Appeal
• Pronouncement Date: 17-01-2020
• Appeal Filed By: Assessee
• Order Result: Allowed
• Bench Allotted: DB
• Next Hearing Date: 05-09-2019
• Assessment Year: 2010-2011
• Appeal Filed On: 12-05-2015
• Result in Favour of: Assessee
• Court: TRIBUNAL
• Section: 64; 43; 48; 73; 72; 13

Judgement Text

[ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] ! ''#''$#%&#'() * !' # $ % & % '( & ) *!) $+,-. / ) 012 /1' ' / 3 .' '%#+#'(,-) . '%#+ (/0#$#%) 1 ) '/ 4 5 !'#$ 6$67$, 5 / [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 2 7$7#$$ ' 58 5 9 ! ' ' # $ ! ' ' #$ ! % & ' ' '(' ' ( ! ' 5. ) . ' / 554( (0 4 5 4 :6 5 !4 '; 4 $< :$ % 5 4=4>&:7$ 6'54( 485 $-6%6&5 4 ( :7$ /? [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 3 5'-6<6# 458 8 8 84 5 4 ' 5 * !'#$ 4 :65 4 4 $-7 4 4 4 ('0 '55 /4 @ 4> 5 5* !' ( 4 5 4 ? 5 4A 5 ( / 4 5 4 45 4 848 '? /4445 54 5 / (4 8 4A ( 4 / ;4A 454 4 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 4 5 4 ( $7 5 5 4 4844 / 5 /! 4 8 / 8 5 5 5 ( 4 8( * !' 4 ? 5 #(5 (454A 5;4 4 4 4 ; 4 4A 42 4 4 44 48 (54 - ( * 5 ) 01 (/ * !' 8 B 5 (0 ( 5 4 :6 5 4 4? /;4 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 5 5 4 ( / ( 85 * !' 4 B4 8 4A / 8/ 5 ( * 5 8 ' 5 9 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 6 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 7 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 8 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 9 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 10 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 11 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 12 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 13 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 14 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 15 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 16 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 17 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 18 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 19 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 20 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 21 , ?4 /*.' 5 8 / 84 4 9 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 22 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 23 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 24 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 25 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 26 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 27 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 28 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 29 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 30 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 31 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 32 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 33 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 34 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 35 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 36 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 37 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 38 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 39 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 40 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 41 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 42 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 43 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 44 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 45 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 46 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 47 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 48 : ( ( ( 4 5 8' 554 ; 4 5 (05 ( :654 8 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 49 (05 B4 84 8!4 54/ $<<-/( 84(5 @' ) 0C5/!4 5 B44 / * !'#$ '* 5 4 4 4 B 5D 5) B2 / 45 !' % 77+& <: !'' 6+ %)2& E 4 4 4 45' 45F* 5 * ' !' !' -7< 2 -$7 .7$- $+$$7$, ' 4 4B 5D/ 45 !'3 !*76!''$7+ 45D. [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 50 45 !' 66,!''+6E 44B 45 !' 02( /*6-$!'' $+7 E ? A ' 85 * !' ( '( 4 458489# *8 ' $ ! * !' -6!''+6% & ' ( 8 !'G ++!''66% & 6 '/ ( !' :!''+-% & - !'8 )(* 6-,!''$6,%. & , 3F !' <40 $ (!*/ 4 5 F;4 6,,:5$<+-% & 'B F)(*) !' # !!! 3,7<57$:% & 0 6 $)3!5 4 2 (4)(* B/8 / 6 )> ! (4 )( * !' :7 :7< %! & - 3 ( !' # : !''4 +(( 5 4 ( *) !' ( ?554 44 4 5 545 / (4 8 4A ( 4 / ; 4A 454 45 4 '454 8 /;/?! 54 * 4 5 0 8 554 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 52 4 5 45 84A /8/5( 8 44 5 0 4 A / A 4 5 4 48 4 ,,%& 5 4 * 4 4 4 4 5 ') 05(/ 5 !!844)$ ' ( 4 A 8 4A ( 4 4 4 / '( 45 5 (0 ( / * !' 85 5 / ? 4 4/A / 84A /8/ 5 ( 4/ / 4 4 4 (4A /8 / 5( [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 53 ,> ?7 '' ' ? > >'*6' @? ' )' '' ' > > ' *6'> @? #0 # 3 ' ' ' '0 '(-' ' ' /#' # 'A#> 6 ' ' # '' )' ! 'A##7 .2@1. ,.@:1131%+: ?+6 @?6'.@)?' #># '' # ' > @ ? # ' ' # '' ! ' ) ' '# ) '5# ' ' 0 22) ' ; # ' ' ' &' ; # ' << [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 60 ' ! ' ''' ' # ' < < & %2 B' ( ' ' ' ' ' # ' ' &' '; # + -% C/ # < < ' ' ' # # & < ' < (; '# ' & ' + %. #'# ' # ' ' ; # 7.2@ 1., .@ : 1131% + : ? + 6 @?6'$ ' < < # #' < ' < &' &# ;< + +' +-*/ .0$% -+/;<+ 67* 5 10 1(#?0' $8 ( ' 33 '' 0' ( ' [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 61 ' -/ ( '' & 4 ' 4 ' 4 4 ' &;'# > 4B4 * ' ''' '& > 3C3. 7 .1C>1 1$12 93 4C8' ' 8 ' ' ;<+ ' ;' '* +' + -$./.0$%D-$./+%1 ;< + %2 ' %. ' %. # ' 4' %2 ! '4;<+ 4 67*5 ' -11./1C0C2< ' '*+' + - / ' ' ' ' ' ! ' ' *+' +-$./.0 ' ;' 7.2@1.,.@:1131%+: ? +6@?6'1 ' ' E 8 * +' +-$./.0$%-+/ [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 62 ;' ' 5 # $$%# + 22-/ ' ## '#' ) . # $$2# ) '# ' ' ' & '' # ) ;'# '# )'# ' #) ' ' '' ;'# ' ' ' ' '' %2 %. ' ; ' '' '' ' & ' ' ' B' %$# ' # ' # # ' # (6 D' ' ' ' 6 )'# ' # ) # )#' ' ' ' ' ' ' '' # ' '' # ' ;<+8 ' ;< * ;' ' + -*/6'- &7 1 11$ , & 7 2 11$# % ' #11$/;< ' ' ' [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 63 ' # '' # ' & + ;< ! ' ' ' '# # ' 8 ' '& ' 4 $'' 8B 5 D 45 !'( (/% &)E4*( !'%7 7+& 67 !'' , ! 5 ( 4 5 ' 4( /8 4 8 4 4A / 8/ 5 ( 5 * !'%& ( / ( 9 =' '' & ( 3-/#* ' ' ' & ;# 71 ' ' 7C [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 64 '' ' ' # ' '' ' ; # # '( ' E)' # & ' # ' # '' # # - /' E # ' ' ' & $ $6E ; 5 5 54 5 4/D ' *+' +,( % & 44454A 4* ;8 45 45* !'0454A ; 4 / 4 5 4 45 /' ( [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 65 / 4 8 4 4/5 84A / 5 ( ' 5 444 554 4445 484A ( 4 ; / B4 (0 (54:6* !' (0 (54:6 5 B4 54 4 4 4/ B4 !48 5 B4 84 4 0-, 9 =( '' ' ' ' ;# 6 71 ''7C '' [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 66 ; ' ' # ' '' ' ; # #( E)' # - /0 ? ' + -*/6 ' ' ' 3' E F $-E ((* !'#! 4 :767$, 0 84 8 / 5 (0 (54:6 9 =( '' ' ' ' ;# 6 71 ''7C '' ; ' ' # [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 67 ' '' ' ; # #( E)' # - /E $, * 4 5 (/ !' ((0 ( 5 4:6 /5 B4 ) !' ( ' * 4 45 45' 4 5 / ) 0 3 ( !'? !'67.7$6 9 22 ! ' '& ' 5 ( D -/D D < & * < & ( ' ' ' ' [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 68 ' .C1? 1+ 6) E G ( ) ' ' )' '' !' # ' & ' ' $:*4 4 44 5 4 5 ' 4 5 18 ( !'!':<7 7$7 9 $ ( 0 ! &+ ' ! 4 4 ')' ! & & ' ! & ' ) ' ( ! 0'# ''' ' )' # # # & ! [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 69 18 & ' & ! ;< 6! , ; ;' ' +8> - / ! ' )#' ' ( ! 0' ;< 4 & '! # ''''' 4 ;< E ;' * , 6 , ,G ,( - / ' # 3 ' ;< E;' ' ! # & ! ;< &' ' ' ; '8 H$C1ICC0#& '# ' ' ! ' ' 3!'* +# +6>H$C1ICC0# -' C/9 4& ' # ! ''' # ' ! D !' # 4 +' ) ;' J -$$/ G , ( - / & '' ?' ) ' ' # & ' ! + 3 & # & & ' '( 3 ' '( #'! # 8 ?0 0' ! # & [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 71 ' & & & ' & < < ' ' ' & ! ' & & ! 5 & ' ' (! + & '# & ' $! 40 B 4 4 /* !'45 *) !'5 4 5 4 ( B4 44A ( ' 5 54 44 8 /44A ( '/ A ( [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 72 54 ( ' !' ( / 5 8/ / A 4 (4A ( 8( * !'5444 (85 45 (4 5 554 54 / /A /! 554 4 A / ; 4A 5 / A ( ' 554 44 454 4 5 484/ 44 5544:6848 * !'5 ( 4 F; 85 7$7:7$, 4:6%$&54';0 9 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 73 = B&K5 # '( ! '# # 6 #K -/ )' ' 'D -/ ' ' D - / # * $ D -/ ! # ! ;'+ F $+ 44 8 / 7$7#$$ 5 488 ' ( D . ; 8 ; 4 5 8 :6 B 45!'?(.3 ) B4 !'$<7$$'D 0 5B 5D; D . 'D ( [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 74 (5D. 4 5 E G B ' -$C2/ $$ 0 C2 -?/ 4 4 4 45 4 !4#; ?554 ( 5 A 5 44 / D 5 (( 54 40 ; (( 8 4 5 !8 (/ D 4?554 4 4 / A / ; (4 8( ' 8 4 5 A / ( 54 ' 4 ( 5 4%&8 A / 5 4 4 J%&8 5 0 5 ( 54 A / ' D [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 75 5 458 5 * !'444 54 /4 4 4 / A / 5 A 4 / 5 :6! 44 5 ?554 8 4 85 4 '* !'4 ?554 48 5 4 !48 A A / 405A /* !' ( 4 5 A / '45A /( 544 4 /* !'8 0/?554 0 8!4/ /* !'48 [ITA NO.318/IND/2015] [SMT. ANNAPURNA MISHRA, BHOPAL] 76 54 4 5 4 85 54 4 B 5 5 A / ( ?554 / 08( 5 4 ' 4 5 5 4?5 54 4 45 A 8 5 E 4 A 84 5 5 ; 45B 4 :654! 4 ?554 8 /* !';4 8 4 ?554 44A $