Appeal Details
Counselvise Citation
[2010] 135 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 3109 (ITAT-PUNE)
Assessee PAN
Bench
Appeal Number
CRN Number
Duration Of Justice
1 year(s) 7 month(s) 12 day(s)
Appellant
Respondent
Appeal Type
Income Tax Appeal
Pronouncement Date
30-11-2010
Appeal Filed By
Department
Order Result
Dismissed
Bench Allotted
Not Allotted
Assessment Year
misc
Appeal Filed On
17-04-2009
Judgement Text
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
Other Referred Cases
-
Laws Referred To
-
1:1 Consultation on Salary Structuring
₹1
Consultation on Entity Formation
₹0
360 Brand Audit (30 mins)
₹299
Object Clause - Merchant Banking Business
Mehul₹100
No Objection Letter for Use of Property – Partnership Firm
₹0
Finance Bill, 2026: Key GST Reforms that will Reshape Compliance and Cash Flows
Team Counselvise - February 03, 2026
Transfer Pricing and International Tax Reforms under Finance Bill, 2026: A Practical Overview
Team Counselvise - February 07, 2026
Residency Rules: Income Tax Act, 1961 vs Income Tax Bill, 2025 — A Subtle Yet Significant Shift!
Team Counselvise - February 18, 2026