, , .. , .., . . . 605/ / 2016 * * : 2008009 * 8 3 (1), < =>< . . .: 9303 < A : * .. =>< A : B , D =E E : 03 . 08 . 2016 G E : 03 . 08 . 2016 J * * 2008009 *K J D J 8 (), 02 E,1961 A 14 3(3) K M 02.03.2015 DNG O P Q* O Q A 2. = TU V W X DJ 8 () = M 29.10.2013, 02.06.2014, 13.10.2014 23.02 .2015 . . . 605 / / 2016 * , 2 A *K A ZP Q X X 8 () = DJ 8 () *K A K A 3. A , DJ =E =E X , D X , DJ D =E 8 () * 4. O O Z X X A P *K , *K A P * X (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) G = A (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) * X X A8 M M G => ,. (SINE QUA NON) M , = C = , = C , = , DE = E> , C =, A K* M * * * X EF J (1978 597; 1 248) = P * X , P EF K X X K E K X A (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) = *0 * X * = P, *K E M , X *K = = M M , *K A =U DJ 8 () = V M DJ . . . 605 / / 2016 * , 3 8 () *K E K DE * M 6. K, *K A WA XKO A 03.08.2016 P JD X /0 /0 (..) (.. ) M : 03.08.2016 = D : < , =>< , 8 () , 8 , D =E , *