Dr. Nallamadi Shashidhar Reddy V. The Union of India

WP/37114/2022

AI Insights

The case involves a group of petitioners, all medical graduates, who were admitted to the 7th respondent institution (MNR Medical College) based on their merit ranking. However, the institution was later de-recognized by the NMC, leading to the petitioners losing their admissions and facing potential career impacts. The petitioners sought a writ of mandamus to reallocate them to other recognized medical colleges, arguing that the actions of the respondents violated Article 14 of the Constitution. The court examined the procedures followed by the NMC and MARB in de-recognizing and subsequently restoring the recognition of the 6th respondent-College, and the adequacy of infrastructure and faculty at that institution.

• Counselvise Citation: [2022] 140 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 733803 (HC-TELANGANA)
• Appeal Type: Others
• Pronouncement Date: 28-11-2022
• Assessment Year: misc
• Laws Referred To: Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Article 14 of the Constitution of India
• Result in Favour of: Partly Allowed
• Court: HIGH COURT
• Department Lawyers: B YADAV; GORANTLA PUJITHA; A PRABHAKAR RAO; D PRASAD
• Assessee Lawyers: S REDDY; G V SHIVAJI
• Keywords: Certiorari; Certiorari; Mandamus; Writ petition; Medical College Recognition; Supernumerary Seats
• Section: 151 CPC

Judgement Text

"t [ 3318 ] HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (SPecial Original Jurisdiction) N/ONDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF NOVEIVBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO- PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO ' WRIT PETITION Nos.37114.tnd 42917 of 2022 WRtT PETITION NO:37114 OF 2022 Between: 1. Dr. Nallamadi Shashidhar Reddy, S/o Sri. N. Krishna Reddy, Aged about 26 years, R/o l7-l-3834.1/BOIA-4lll, Brundavan Colony, Champapet, Saidabad, Hyderabad - 500059. 2. Dr.T. Prashanth, S/o Sri. T. Chandra Sekhar, Aged about 27 yearc,No l-1-257/2, RBI Colony, Mohan Nagar, Kothapet, Saroornagar, Ranga Reddy _ 500035. J Dr. Vanam Bharath, S/o Sri. V. Yadaiah, - Aged about 37 yea*, R/o 3-116, Khella Bazar, Devarakonda, Nalgonda - 508248. Dr. Maganti Devasish, S/o Sri. M.V.R.S. prasad, Aged about 25 years, R/o P 1 No. 244, H. No. 5-4- 1 663/1, phase_ t, Sharada Nagar, Vanasthalipuram, LB Nagar, Ranga Reddy _ 500070 Dr. E. Chandana, D/o Sri. E. Manipal Reddy, Aged about 29 years, R/o H. No. 8-4-12135, Sairam Nagar Colony, Phase-2, Karmanghat, Ranga Reddy - 500079. Dr. Sweta Jambi, D/o Sri. J. Nagaraju, Aged about 27 yeats,No 8-2-269/3/64, Mayfair Apartments, Road No. 2,BanjaraHills, Hyderabad - 500034. Dr. Y. Sneha, D/o Sri. Y.V. Narsimha Reddy, Aged about 27 yea*,No l-241/217,7N Road, Bhavani Nagar, Kapra, ECIL, Secunderabad - 500062. 4 . i. I i I ! i I I i I I I I I t I I B E I I h -' 8. Dr. Sravanthi C., D/o Sri. C..tanaradhan Reddy, Aged about 34 years, Rio H. No. 2_3711, Chatanpally, Shadnagar, Mahabubnaqar. 5092 I (r. 9. Dr. Nedunuri Srujan, S/o Sri. N. Venugopal, Aged about 25 years, R/o Flat No. I 0l , Sarah Enclave, plot No. 49tB/C, Gayatri Nagar, Borabanda. Hyderabad _ 50001g. 10. Dr. Ibrahimpur Priya Bhargavi, D/o Sri. I. Nagshetty, Aged about 26 years,R/o t2-2_568/2+/a, GuJimaliapur, Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad - 50002g\" i l.Dr. E. Syamala, D/o Sri. E. Sanjecvappa, Aged about 45 years, R/o euarter No. HAI, Area Hospital premisr:s, Mandamarri, RamakrishnapLrr. Aclilabad _ 504301. \"- 12. Dr. C. Pavan Kumar, S/o Sri. C. papaiah, Aged about 38 years, R/o l l-12_4,l,lot No. 4, Road No. 1, Income Tax Colony, Alkapuri Colony, Ramakrishnapuram, Ranga Reddy * 500102. /- 13. Dr. Arumilli Vamsidhar, S/o Sri. A.V. Vara prasad, Aged- about 26 years, R/o II. No. 35-42_6/1, Railway Station Road, . Tanuku, West Godavari. Andhra pr.aclesh _ 534211 . /- 14. Dr. Kota N. Vinootlma, D/o Sri. K. .tayaraju, Aged about 27 years. No l-92014, Sundaraiah Nagar, Madhira, Khammam - 5Ol-2O3. - . 15. Dr. Suthari Pranathi, D/o Sri. S. Srinivas Reddy, Aged abour 25 years,No2-5-g6/1, Ward_3, Biahmanwadi, Narayanpet, Mahbubnagar - 5092 10. ' /- 16. Dr. M.S. Latha, D/o Sri. M. Manyayy-4 Aged about 25 years, R /o I -9- 1 55/6,-5. S. Takees, Kollapur, Mahbubnagar 509102. 17. Dr. Venumuddala Shilpa Reddy, D/o Sri. V. Ram Gopal Reddy, Aged about 30 years, R/o 3-14-g/6, Srinivasapuram Colony, - Ramanthapur, Amberpet, Hyderabad _ 5000 I 3. { I T t I 18 Dr. Gundareddl,gari Rishikanth Reddy, S/o Sri. G. Veera Rcddy, Aged about 26 ycars, R/o MiG 200. APHB Colony, Zahirabad,Merhk 501120. AND The Union of India, Ministry ol Health and liarnily Welfare, Nirman Bhavan, Ncw Dclhi - 1 10001, Rep. by its Secretary. 3. The Medical Assessment and Ratings Board, The Natiorral Medical Cornmission, Pocket I 4, Scctor 8, Drvaraka, Phase - I, New Delhi - I I 0001 , Rep., by its President. 4. The State of Tclangana Health, Medical and Family Welfare Department, Rep.. by its Sccrclary. 5. Koloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences Nizampura, Waranga[, Telangana - 506007, Rep., by its Rcgistrar. 6. MNR Medical College & I-Iospital, MNR Nagar, Fasalwadi, Sangareddy - 502294, Rep., by its Authorized Representative. ...PEl Il lONtrRS RESPONDENTS 2. The Natior-ral Medical Conrmission Pocket 14, Sector 8, Dwaraka, Phase I, New Delhi - I1000i, Rep., by its Chairman. I i : : I I Between: Dr.Pothuganti Ravi, 5,/o. P.Rajaiah, a9ed 32 years, Vo:H.No.1-60, zFD-: Narasaipalle Maddur, Narasaipalle, Warangal. Telangana. d*f\"* 2. Dr. R.Thilak. 5/o. R.Ushaiah, aged 37 years. Vo:H.No.20-156/5/1/2,- d- R.B.Nagar, Samshabad, Rangareddy. Telangana. 3. Dr. M.Ravi Kanth.5/o. Mohan Rao. I , aged 40 years, R/o:H.No.MB 28, ert !1,>-4\") Bungalows Area, Manjur Nagar, Ndar Area Hospital, Bhupalapalli, Warangal, Telangana. JJ* 4. Dr.5.Ravi Shankar. 5/o.S.Veeri Raiu. Aged 36 years. R/o:H.No.l-68/1, uo >|\"f,-y Main Road; Seetharamapuram, . Dummugud(M), B.Kothagudem. 5, Dr.T.Pradeep. S/o. T.Prabhakar, _ , r aged 31 years, R/o.Flat.No.6-3, c)c< >l \"rtl'd Kasu Apartments, Old Airport Road, New Bowenpally, Secunderabad, Hyderabad. 6. Dr.Apoorva Rao. D/o. D.Narasingha Rao, aged27 years, R/o:H.No.7-1O7, o\" jl+*&J Plot No.96, Duggiyala Street, Greenlands, Manchirevula, Ranga Reddy, Telanagana. WRIT PETITION NO: 4291 2 OF 2022 7 Dr.K.Hari Priya, D/o. K.Sahadev, , aged 2B years. R/o:H.N o.17-2'429, cx' 9l' '^\"^\" Kurumaguda, Arya samaj Bhavan, Saidabad' Hyderabad, 500051. B. Dr.Waseema Unnisa, C/o. Md.Zia ul Rahaman Charri. aged 28 years, R/o:H.No.5-5-8, ,* Sf'^5-} Housing Board Colony, Zaheerabad, Medak, Telangana, 5O222O. 9. Dr.P.Manasa, D/o. P.Madhusudhan' aged 29 years, R./o:H.No.2-1O-868' oee- Jyothi Nagar, Karimnagar District, Telangana, 505001. lO.Dr.D.Soumya, D/o. D'Narasimha Swamy' aged 35 Years, Vo:H.No.3-4-478, o.t Sudha Nagar, Hanumakonda' Telangana, 506011. 11. Dr.Ramu Chandragiri' S/o. Yadagiri' aged 38 years, Vo:H.N o.8-95/61, 'o<-L- Dwaraka Nagar, Phase -ll, Narasaipalle, Medipalli, Rangareddy' Telangana. 1 2. Dr.K.Poojitha, D,io. K-Suneel, aged 3l Years, R/o:Flat No.404, @ H Towers, Mamta College Road, Kranthi Nagar, KanahaPuram Haveli, Khammam, 5O7OO2. s}-u* > '-u-+ >f--i^r >ti-x str-r 'I 3.Dr.M.Uday Kumar' 5,/o. Prabhakar' aged 34 years, Wo:2-77, ocl Siddanki, Jellagam' Warangal, 506201. >l+; l4.Dr.R.Yashwanth Kumar, 5/o. Raj kumar' 6 c'L Aged 28 years, Vo.3-6-225' Adarsha Nagar' Karimnagar-505O01. Y 'I 5.Dr.K.Kavya, D/o. K.Rajendra Prasad' aged 27 ydars. R/o:H.N o.2-12-54. Vayuputra Colony' Vidyaranyapuri. Hanumakonda, Warangal-5060O9. elt ' sl.a.^r 16.Dr.K.Sowmya, D/o. K.Ravi Prakash Reddy' aged 2}yerrrs, R/o:H.N o.3-g4, 6\". gl.,Lo-t VenkataPur, Chftnan 6untaPalli' Mahaboobna g ar -509206. 17.Dr.6.Rashmi, D/o. 6.Chand16 Sekhar, aged 2 6 yea 15, R/o : H. N o -2-4-1204 / I / 10 /10 6 / 2, Vidya Nagar Colony' T.V. Tower, ae- 9 Hanumakonda, Warangal-506009' l8.Dr.J.Meghana, D/o. Srinivas Rao' aged 28 years, R/O:H.No-82O17 ' cI-!' Sumadhura Acro Police, 148/2E, Nanakramguda, 6achibowli' Rangareddy District-500032. *'-l,^-' 19.Dr.Md.5hujayath' S/o- Md. Shafy Miyan' aged32 years, R/o:H.No.7-2-792' oct 9 Mankamma Thota' Karimnagar. Telangana-505O01 . )--4\"^^ 21. Dr.K.Prirvalika, D/o. K-Bucchayya' aged 33 Years, R/o:H.No.8-33' 6ollagudenr, SadasivaPeta(M)' Nandikandi, Medak-500001' Warangal, Tela.ngana' err- 9 a^lv 20.Dr.Sana, D/o. Md.Akram Quareshi' aged 26 years, Vo:H-N o.5-6-268/C' N'\"r,v ori\"orra, OPP.SBI, \"'- -S|*!\"^Y NamPally, HYderabad-500001' l+-\"-r 6 East Brundavan Colony, Bode Uppal, JCR High School. Ghatakeskar(M)-5O0092. 23. Dr.N.6outhami, D/o. Ashok Rao, aged 26 years, R/o:H.N o.13-85/1, 6c- Main Road, ShankaramPet, Medak, Telangana-502271 . 24. Dr.Md.Adil Faraz, S/o. Dr.Mohamman Afzal Baslra' aged 27 years, R/o:H.N 0.8-2-602/20/A/1' az **^ r Road No 10, Zehera Nagar, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad. - 50OO34. 25. Dr.K.Manasa, D/o. K.Naga Raju' aged 28 years, R/o:H.N o.5-82/13. ott- Yenukonda, Opp.ZPH5. Mahaboob Nagar, Telangana-5O9001. sl.-- L- 26. Dr.Md.Tamjeed Absar, 5/o. Md.Abdul Moqueenl aged 27 yea rs, R/o : H. N o.9 -1'2O / A/ 1 / 12 /1, o \"z- <)-+l Hasam Nagar, Langar House' Golconda, Telangana-5O0008- 27. Dr.CH.Madhukar Reddy, 5/o. Shankar Reddy' aged29 years, R./o:H.No.1-2, ' c>cr- ii r^f Parvathipur, Near Aurora College' Ghatakeshara, Medipalli' Telangana-500098' 28. Dr.K.Poorna Chandar, 5/o. Krishnayya' aged34years, Vo:H.No.2-174/1, Dec- Sri Lakshmi Nagar, Colony Extension, Chittoor, Telangana. 22. Dr.J.Dharani. D/o. J.Canga Raju, ^ r _L aged26 years, R/o:H.No.l-11/B/8. 'D4 5r.*' 29. Dr.K.Soujanya, D/o. K.Karunakar, r , aged 31 years, R/o:H.No-8'26, oc' 2l^b4 BC ColonY, MusaPet Vemula' Mahaboob Nagar' Telangana-5OO93 8O' d-*}- *r* 4- 30. Dr.E.Devi Elwaramma' D/o. E.Satyanarayana' aged 26 years, R/o:H.N o.2-9-7O-1, o1a 9 z*J- Ashram Street, Allagadda, Kurnool District' 3l.Dr.B.Salya Kiran' 5/o.Siva Subramanyam' aged2lyears, R/o:H.No.2-2-438, \"l- 9|J Kishanpura, Hanumakonda, Narasaipalle' Warangal, Telangana-506001. 32. Dr.R.6napika, D/o. R.Krishna Murthy' aged 30 years, R/o:H-N o.3-9-227, u'- 9 -* 5halivahana Nagar, ReddY ColonY' Hanumakonda, Warangal, Telangana-5O600l' 33. Dr.Ayesha Sama, D/o' Md'Owaisuddin' aged 30 years, R/o:H.No.8-1'346/5/F' \"u-- 5Yo.i Sabza Colony, Shaikpet Reliance Mart Colconda, Telangana. €rc: ..... Petitioners And 1. The Union of lndia' ReP., bY its secretary, Mininry of Health and Family Welfare' Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi-l10001' 2. The National Medical commission' Rep. bY its Chairman' Pocket 14, Sector 8' Dwaraka' Phase-l' New Delhi-l10O01. 3. The Medical Assessment and Ratings Board' Rep. bY its President, The National Medical Commission' Pocket 14,Sector B, Dwaraka' Phase-l' New Delhi-l10001' 4- The State of Telangana' Rep. by its Secretary' Health, Medical and Family Welfare Department' Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad. 5. The Director of Medical Education, Covernment of Telangana. Hyderabad. 6. Kaloji Narayana Rao Univeristy of Health Sciences' Rep. by its Registrar, NizamPura, Warangal, Telangana-506007 7. MNR Medical College & HosPital' Rep.. by its Authorized Representative MN R Nagar, Fasalwadi, Sangareddy-5O2294, .... Respondents Petition under Article 226 oI lhe constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of ltilandamus, declaring the impugned action of respondents 1 to 6, in not making re-allotment of the petitioners, to any other recognized Medical college, in view of de-recognizing and withdrawing the permission granted in favour of 7th respondent institution, vide proceedings No. NIVC/UGR/2020/0001 15/018396-96' dated. .18/05/2022, issued by the 3rd respondent, though petitioners were allotted to the 7th respondent institution, on the basis of their merit ranking and allotment through 6th respondent institution, thereby subjecting the petitioners to lose their career, as illegal arbitrary and unco nstitutio nal and violation of Article 14 of the constitution of lndia, consequently direct the respondents to re-allot the petitioners to any other recognized and valid permission holding Medical college by creating supernumerary posts. '/ t f t I Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue an order, direction or writ, more so in the nature of writ of certiorarified mandamus, calling for the records pertaining to the impugned order bearing No.NMClUGRl2020l000115/037820-25, dated 07 09.2022 issued by the 3rd Respondent, quash the same and consequently, direct the Respondent Nos.2, 4 and 5 to create supernumerary seats in the existing rec,lgnized Government or Private lvledical Colleges in the State of Telangana and rerallocate the Petitioners herein to the said supernumerary seats. lA NO: 1 OF 2022 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the :ircumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the impugned order bearing No. NMC/UGR12')2010001151037820-25. dated 07 09 2022 issued by the 3rd Respondent. lA NO: 2 OF 2022 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to constitute a committee to enquire into the deficienciers existing in the 6th Respondent college. Counsel for the Petitioners: SRl. S. NAGESH REDDY Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SMT B. KAVITA YADA,V SC FOR CENTRAL GOVERNI IENT Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 & 3: M/S GORANTLA SRI RANGA PUJITHA, SC FOR NATIONAL NIEDICAL COMMISSION Counsel forthe Respondent No.4: GP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARI: Counsel for the Respondent No.S: SRI A. PRABHAKAR RAO, SC FOR KNR UNIVERT}ITY Counsel for the Respondent No.6: SRI D. SRINIVAS PRASAD SC FOR MNR MEDICAL COLLEGE Between: Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of Mandamus, declaring the impugned action of respondents 1 to 6, in not making re-allotment of the petitioners, to any other recognized Medical college, in view of de-recognizing and withdrawing the permission granted in favour of 7th respondent institution, vide proceedings No.NMC/UGR/2020/000115/018396-96, daIed. 1810512022, issued by the 3rd respondent, though petitioners were allotted to the 7th respondent institution, on the basis of their merit ranking and allotment through 6th respondent institution, thereby subjecting the petitioners to lose their career, as illegal arbitrary and u nconstitutional and violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of lndia, Consequently direct the respondents to re-allot the petit;oners to any other recognized and valid permission holding Medical College by creating supernumerary posts. WRIT PETITION NO:42912 OF 2022 I IA NO: 1 0F 2022 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the c rcumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court m ay be pleased to direct the respondent to take action forthwith to Re-allocate the petitioners to any other IVledical College within the State of Telangana' having /alid Recognition and permissionforpursuingPostGraduation(i.e')MD/IVsintherespectivedisciplines, in which the petitioners have been admitted, for the acadermic year commencing from 2021-2022, pending disposal of the above writ petition' Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI' G'V' SHIVAJI Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI GADI PRAVEEN KJMAR (DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL oF INDIA) Counsel for the Respondent Nos'2 & 3: M/S GORANTLA :iRl RANGA PUJITHA' SC FOR NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION Counsel for the Respondent Nos'4 & 5: GP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FAMILY WELF, RE Counsel for the Respondent No.6: SRI A' PRABHAKAR F:AO' SC FOR KNR UNIVERS,ITY Counsel for the Respondent No.7: SRI D' SRINIVAS PRASAD SC FOR MNR MEDICAL COLLEGE The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER The Court made the following: ORDER I HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI AND HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO W.P.Nos.31114 and 42912 OF 20ZZ COMMONNORDER: (Per IIon'ble Sri-[ustice Abhinand Kunrat Shal'ili) Since the issue involr,cd in both these rvrit petidons ls onc and the same, thelr are being heard toge ther ard disposecl oF br, way of this common order. For the sake of convenicnce, thc facts in W.P.No.37i 14 oi 2022 are hereunder discusscd. W.P.No.37114 of 2022 is filed seeking thc fcilorving rcLief: \"..to issue an otder, direction or writ, morc so, in the nature of writ of Certiorari, calling for the rccords pertaining to the impugned order bcaring No.NMC/UGR/2020/000115/031820 25, dated 07.09.2022 issued by lhe S respondenr. quash the same and consequcndy, direct rcspondcnt Nos.Z, 4 and 5 to create supemumerary scats in the cxisting recognized Govenment or Private Medical Collcgcs in the State of Telangana and reallocate thc pctitionets herein to the said supernulnerary seats and pass such other order or ordets as this Hofl'ble Court may deem fit and necessary in ti.re clcumstances of the case.\" t ,]' i I Fleari Sl S.Nagesh Reddy, Sd G'V\"Shn'aii, lcarncC cotinsci appearine lrrr the petitioncrs, Smt B I(avita Yadav, iearned Stancling Counsei lor Centrai Government appearing for thc 1\" respondent, Smt Gorantla Sti Ranga Pujita, learned Standing (-ounscl appearing For 2td ^,td 3'd resp<:ndents, lcarncd Gove rnme nt irleader for Medical, Health and Family Welfarc appcaring fot the 4s rcspondent, Sri A.Prabhakar Rao' lcarned Standing Counsel appearing for the 5e respor'dent-Unviersity and Sri D.srinivas Prasad, learned Standing Counsel appearing lor thc 6'r' re spondcnt-College. Learned counscl appearing for the lletitioners had contcndcd that the recognition graflted in fat'our of the 6m respondcnt-College was withdrawn by the National Medical Commission (for short 'NMC) uide ptoceedttgs dated 1,8-05-2022 and whilc withdrawing the recogrrir'ion, thc NMC has stated that the students, who were studying in the 6'h respondcnt-College, would be re-allocated to other Medical Collegcs. Flowevcr, the 6th respondent has preft:rred ftst appeal beforc the NMC and the same was dismissed :rnd later, the 6'h J respoodent tras prcfcrreci second appeal beiorc thc (_rntral Governmeri and thc Central Govcrnmcnt has disposcci o[ rhc said se cond appeai uide order datcd 16.08.2022 and remancicci rhe matter back to the Medical Assessment and Ratings Board (ftrt short 'MARB). Thercafter, the MARB has issued proceedir.rqs dated 07 09-2022 stating rhar the inspecrion, r,rhich rva.s conducted during thc month of August, holds good fr;r rhe ir,h respondent For making admissions for academic year 2A22 23 and also holds good lor the previous academic year 2021 22. Based upon thc proceedings issued by the I ,LA,RB datcd 07-09 2022, the 6,h respondent as well as the NMC arc conrending rhat the recognition granted in favour o[ the 6,h rcspondenr has bccn restored and that the students who were admitted for tirc academic year 2021-22 can pursue their PG Courscs in the 6'h respondent-Coilege . I-earned counsel appearing for the petitioners had lurther contended that a perusal of NMC Act, no where it gives authority to the NMC or MARR or even to the Cer.rtral Government to restore the recognition which rvas aircady 'rthcira vlr aird flo procccdings rvcrc issuerj by thc NNiC, Ccntrai Gor.crnrnent or t iAitB restoring thr: rc.cognrtrort rn far.r>ur oi thc 5.h rcspor-rcient cxcept making a t;a1d statement in thc proceedings dated 07 -'09 2022, rvhercin it orLly states that the inspecuon, rvhich was conducted in the month of Augost,2022, l.rolds goocl lor making admissrons for the acaderni c year 2022_23 and aiso holds good for thc prcvious academic year 2O2l _22. No speaking ordcrs were passed restoring the tecop;nition in favour of the 6d, respondenr and rhe petitioners apprehend that if recognition is not extendcd . to the 6,h respondent_Coltege, the valuablc carecr of the petirioners would be effected. Thcrefore, appropriatc orders be passed in the writ petit_ion by directing the respondents to issue revised proceedings restoriflg the recognition rn lavour of the 6,h respondent so as to enable the petitioners to study P.G Medicai Course irr a recognized lnstltutl()n. Learned counscl appearing for thc petitiolcrs had further contended that therc is no in flras trrcture and fa.culty in the 6tr, tespondent Collcge and in the absence o[ infrrrstrucrure and nuP{., I sP'i I facuitv rn rhc 6,h rcspcncient Coilcge, the petitioners wili be put to irreparable ioss anri the1, 21c not ablc to learn anything in thc 6'h respondent-Collcgc. Learned Standing Counsci appearing for NMC and NLTRB had ccntcnded that thc recognition granted in lavour of thc 6,h respondent has been resrorcd with the issuance o[ procccdings dateci 07-09-2A22 aod even in the website also, it is placed that the recognition has been restored and the admissions in the 6,h respondent-College for the academic year 2021-22 wcre also rcguiarized. Therefore, no further orders need to be passed and the apprehension of the petitioners is totally incorrccr and admissions of the pctitioners have bccn regularized by the NN4C as wel.l as MARB. Learned Standing Counsel appeariag for the 6d. respondent had contended that there is a valid recognition to thc 6'h rcspondent College with the issuance of procee dings dated 0l -09-2022 and necessary inFrastructure is available and qualified faculry was appointed and the petitioners can pursue their P.G. , Courses irr thc 6s respondent-College without any difficuiry. i Flaving consicierecl thc rival submissions made by the learoed counscl on cithcr sicic' this Court is of the -''ic'w that both the Writ Pctitions can be disposed o[ dirccting thc NMC as weil as MARts to Pass a specihc order restoring thc recogniuon in favour of the 6d' respondent-College lor the academic ycar 2021,-22within a pcriod of onc wcek from the d:rte of receipt of a copy of this order' Flowcver' it is clarifted that it will be the responsibility of the NMC as weil as MARB to conduct monthly inspections on thc 6'h respondent-Collcge to ensure that qualihed facuity and necessary inlrachrre is beirLg maintained by the 6th respondent-College' Misccllaneous petitions, if any' pending sha1l stand ciosed' B?'i'Til-t\"f5\"#ll '/rRUE coPY// .EcfiyN oFFlcER 'Ii,\",'ui\"6\".':qt:ffi^,,ilfi$[':#::::]':]::ilJ\"H:: ' If,:,?l':Ef, l;)?1 I'l3il\"i;.;'rii - ir ooor To, Accotdingly, both thc Writ Petitions ate disposed of' No costs 3. The President, Medical Assessment and Ratings Board, The !aJ!ona! .. - fvf \"Oi\"\"l -Co.mission, Pocket 14, Sector 8, Dwiraka, Phase - l, New Delhi - 110001 + The-S-#retary, State of Telangana, Health' Medical and Family Welfare Deoartment. s ini: Reqrstrar, Kalotr Narayana Rao University of Health Sctences' Nizamp-ura, Waran!al, Telanqana - 506007. O fne A,]tnorized Re[resentatiie, MNR Medical College and Hospital, MNR Naoar. Fasalwadi, Sanqareddy 502294. Z in-J Oir\"\"tol. of UeOicuIeducation. Government of Telangana, Hyderabad' I g. One CC to Sri S. Nagesh Reddy Advocate tO-PtL91.- ) 9 iil CCsi- Cp to, MreOicriHelrtn anO Famity Wdtfare, nigh Court for the ! State of Telangana at Hyderabad tqgll r o. ond-ct i; fii. B Kaviiha Yadav (SC for central Government [OPUC] i i. O;; Ca io Smt Gorantla Sri Ranga Pujitha, SC for National Medical Commission [OPUCI 12 oil CC to SriA. Prabhakar Rao, SC for KNR University [oPUCl -^ ^- i5.o;; cC io Sri o. Srinivas Prasad, SC for MNR Medical College [OPUC] 14. One CC to Sri G.V. Shivaji Advocate [OPUC] iS.O\". CC io Srl CaOi Pravden Kumar, beputy-solicitor General of lndia loPUCl 16. Two CD CoPies CHR GJP HIGH COURT DATED:2811112022 ,P s ,.r .1')., . - COMMON ORDER H grtr .* W.P.Nos.37114 and 42912 of 2022 DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITIONS WITHOUT COSTS 1 ( # o 1E L4 ,) It * It s tlJ 'ss,. nA a o; ., // "