Appeal Details
Counselvise Citation
[2010] 135 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 3130 (ITAT-PUNE)
Assessee PAN
Bench
Appeal Number
CRN Number
Duration Of Justice
1 month(s) 2 day(s)
Appellant
Respondent
Appeal Type
Income Tax Appeal
Pronouncement Date
30-11-2010
Appeal Filed By
Assessee
Order Result
Allowed
Bench Allotted
Not Allotted
Assessment Year
misc
Appeal Filed On
28-10-2010
Judgement Text
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
Other Referred Cases
-
Laws Referred To
-
1:1 Consultation on Salary Structuring
₹1
360 Brand Audit (30 mins)
₹299
1:1 Consultation on SME Listing
₹0
No Objection Letter for Use of Property – Partnership Firm
₹0
Memorandum Amendment Resolution
₹0
Transfer Pricing and International Tax Reforms under Finance Bill, 2026: A Practical Overview
Team Counselvise - February 07, 2026
Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT): Comprehensive Overview and Key Changes under Finance Bill, 2026
Team Counselvise - February 06, 2026
When Global Talent Meets GST: The Huawei Secondment Ruling explained
Team Counselvise - March 09, 2026