, , .. , .., . . . 317/ / 2016 + + : 2010011 1 3 5 4 (2), 9 :;9 . . .: = = 8388 9 @ : + . . A , :;9 @ : . . , 1 :5 5 : 14 . 0 9 . 2016 I 5 : 14 . 0 9 . 2016 .., K + + 2010011 +L K 1 K = ()0II, 5,1961 @ 14 3(3) L O 30.11.2015 1QI R S T+ R T @ . . . 317 / / 2016 1 3, 2 2. : WX Y Z [ 1K = () : 0 R @ +L @ +L @ ]S T [ [ = () : 1K = () _ @ A +L @ L @ 3. @ , 1K :5 :5 [ [ 1K = () @ 5 S +L A B E 1; F S = () S 1K :5 :5 [ , 1 [ , 1K 1 :5 = () + 4. R R ] A [ [ @ S +L , +L @ S + [ (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) I : @ (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) + [ [ E= O O I :; ,. (SINE QUA NON) O , : K : , : K , : , 15 : 5; , K :, @ L+ O + + + [ LM K (1978 597; 1 248) : S + [ , S LM L [ [ L 5 3 . . . 317 / / 2016 1 3, 3 [ @ (AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM) : +0 + [ + : S, +L 5 O , [ +L : : O O , +L @ :X 1K = () : { O 1K = () +L 5 3 15 + O 6. L, +L @ |@ }3R @ 14.09.2016 S K1 [ /0 /0 (.. ) (..) O : 14.09.2016 : 1 : 9 , :;9 , = () , = , 1 :5 , +