SHRI Sunil Modi, Anil Modi, Nand Gopal Modi Legal Heirs of Late Shri Radheyshyam Modi S/o Late Shri Gopilal Modi, Sehore V. THE ITO 2(3), Bhopal

ITA 365/IND/2016

• Counselvise Citation: [2016] 132 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 6038 (ITAT-INDORE)
• Duration Of Justice: 1 month(s) 12 day(s)
• Appeal Type: Income Tax Appeal
• Pronouncement Date: 30-05-2016
• Appeal Filed By: Assessee
• Order Result: Allowed
• Bench Allotted: SMC
• Assessment Year: 2007-2008
• Appeal Filed On: 18-04-2016
• Result in Favour of: Assessee
• Court: TRIBUNAL

Judgement Text

VK - V - LA - 363 LS 365@BUNKSJ@2016 LQFUY EKSNH] VFUY EKSNH] UANXKSIKY EKSNH] FLGKSJ 1 VK;DJ VIHYH; VF/KDJ.K VK;DJ VIHYH; VF/KDJ.K VK;DJ VIHYH; VF/KDJ.K VK;DJ VIHYH; VF/KDJ.K BUNKSJ ,D LNL;H; IZDJ.KU;K;IHB % BUNKSJ BUNKSJ ,D LNL;H; IZDJ.KU;K;IHB % BUNKSJ BUNKSJ ,D LNL;H; IZDJ.KU;K;IHB % BUNKSJ BUNKSJ ,D LNL;H; IZDJ.KU;K;IHB % BUNKSJ JH MH JH MH JH MH JH MH- -- -VH VHVH VH- -- - XJKFL;K] U;KF;D LNL; DS LE{K XJKFL;K] U;KF;D LNL; DS LE{K XJKFL;K] U;KF;D LNL; DS LE{K XJKFL;K] U;KF;D LNL; DS LE{K LFKK LFKKLFKK LFKK- -- -YS YSYS YS- -- -LA LALA LA- -- - % % % % ,CHTSIH,E 5650 ,E ,CHTSIH,E 5650 ,E ,CHTSIH,E 5650 ,E ,CHTSIH,E 5650 ,E VK VKVK VK- -- -V VV V- -- -LA LALA LA- -- - % 363 LS 365 % 363 LS 365 % 363 LS 365 % 363 LS 365@BUNKSJ@201 @BUNKSJ@201 @BUNKSJ@201 @BUNKSJ@2016 66 6 FU/KKZJ.K O'KZ % FU/KKZJ.K O'KZ % FU/KKZJ.K O'KZ % FU/KKZJ.K O'KZ % 2005&06 LS 2007&08 2005&06 LS 2007&08 2005&06 LS 2007&08 2005&06 LS 2007&08 LQFUY EKSNH] VFUY EKSNH] UANXKSIKY EKSNH OS@M LO- JH JK/KS;KE EKSNH IZKS- ES- XKSIHYKY JK/KS;KE EKSNH] FLGKSJ CUKE VK;DJ VF/KDKJH 2 3] HKKSIKY VIHYKFKHZ IZR;FKHZ VIHYKFKHZ DH VKSJ LS LOZJH VKKH'K XKS;Y RFKK ,U-MH-IVOK IZR;FKHZ DH VKSJ LS JH VKJ - , - OEKZ] FOHKKXH; IZFRFUF/K LQUOKBZ DH FRFFK 30 - 05 - 201 6 MN~?KKS'K.KK DH FRFFK 30 - 05 - 201 6 VKNSK VKNSK VKNSK VKNSK JH XJKFL;K] JH XJKFL;K] JH XJKFL;K] JH XJKFL;K] U;KF;D LNL; U;KF;D LNL; U;KF;D LNL; U;KF;D LNL; }KJK }KJK }KJK }KJK FU/KKZJ.K O'KZ 2005&06 LS 2007&08 DS FY, FU/ KKZFJRH }KJK ;S VIHYSA VK;DJ VK;QDR VIHY&2] HKKSIKY DS VYX&VYX VKNSKKSA FNUKAD 11-02-2016 VK - V - LA - 363 LS 365@BUNKSJ@2016 LQFUY EKSNH] VFUY EKSNH] UANXKSIKY EKSNH] FLGKSJ 2 RFKK 22-01-2016 DS FO:/N VIHY DS VK/KKJKSA ESA OF.K ZR VK/KKJKSA IJ NKF[KY DH XBZ GSA 2- IZDJ.K DS LAF{KIR RF; FUEU :I LS ;S GSA FD F O}KU VK;DJ VK;QDR VIHY DS LE{K ;S IZDJ.K LQUOKBZ GSRQ FOFHKUU FNUKA DKAS DKS FU;R FKS A BU RKJH[KKSA ESA LS ,D VOLJ DKS NKSM+DJ VU; FDLH HKH R KJH[K IJ FU/KKZFJRH DH VKSJ LS DKSBZ MIFLFKR UGHA GQVK A FO}KU VK;DJ VK;QDR VI HY US FU/KKZFJRH DKS LQUS FCUK IZDJ.K DS RF;KAS IJ LAF{KIR :IK LS PPKZ DJRS G Q, FU/KKZFJRH DH VIHYSA ,D I{KH; VK/KKJ IJ [KKFJT DH GSAA 3- VIHY DH LQUOKBZ DS NKSJKU] FO}KU IZKF/KD`R IZFRFUF/K US BL U;K;IHB LS LQUOKBZ DK ,D VOLJ NSUS DK VUQQJKS/K FD;KA VR%] MLUS BU VIHYKSA DKS IQU%LFKKFIR DJUS DK VUQJKS/K FD;KA 5- FO}KU OFJ'B FOHKKXH; IZFRFUF/K US BU VIHYK SA DKS IQU%LFKKFIR FD, TKUS IJ DKSBZ VKIFRR UGHA DH A 6- ESAUS IK;K FD BU VIHYKSA DH LQUOKBZ ESA FU /KKZFJRH MIFLFKR UGHA JGK FKKA VR%] ;S IZDJ.K FU/KKZFJRH DH VUQIFLFKFR ESA FU.KZF; R FD;S X;S FKSA NWLJS I{K DKS HKH NWLJS I{K DKS HKH NWLJS I{K DKS HKH NWLJS I{K DKS HKH LQUKS LQUKS LQUKS LQUKS A AA A AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM DK FL/NKAR USLFXZD U;K; DH EWYHKWR VO/KKJ.KK GSA INCA/K NWLJS I{K DKS HKH LQUKS NWLJS I{K DKS HKH LQUKS NWLJS I{K DKS HKH LQUKS NWLJS I{K DKS HKH LQUKS A AA A AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM ** DK VFKZ GS FD FDLH HKH O;FDR DKS MLDK LO;A DK CPKO DJUS DK VOLJ FN;K TKUK PKFG,A ;G FL/NKAR IZR;SD LH; LEKT GSRQ VFUOK;Z VFUOK;Z VFUOK;Z VFUOK;Z SINE QUA NON GS TSLS UKSFVL DK GD] IZDJ.K RFKK LK{; IZLRQR DJUS DK GD] IZFRDWY LK{; DK [KAMU DJUS DK GD] IZFR IJH{K.K DK GD] FOF/KD IZFRFUF/KRO DK GD] I{K DKS LK {; DK IZDVU] TKAP DH FJIKSVZ VU; I{K DKS FN[KK;K TKUK VKSJ RDZIW.KZ FU.K Z; ;K LDKJ.K VKNSKA ESAUSSS VK - V - LA - 363 LS 365@BUNKSJ@2016 LQFUY EKSNH] VFUY EKSNH] UANXKSIKY EKSNH] FLGKSJ 3 IK;K FD LQUOKBZ DS GD DKS EKUUH; LOKSZPP U;K;KY; }K JK ESUDK XKA/KH CUKE ;WFU;U VKWQ BFUM;K 1978 ,VKBZVKJ 597( 1 ,LLHLH 248 DS IZDJ.K ESA FU.KZF;R FD;K X;K GS] FTLESA EKUUH; LOKSZPP U;K;Y; US VFHK/K KFJR FD;K GS FD DKSBZ HKH VKNSK IKFJR DJUS LS IGYS MFPR LQUOKBZ DK FU;E VKO ;D GSA ESAUSS IK;K FD ;G NWLJS I{K DKS HKH LQUKS A AUDI ALTERAM PARTEM FU;E DS IZFREKU DK FU.KZ;&IWOZ LQUOKBZ EKUD GSA ESAUSS IK;K FD BL ORZEKU IZDJ.K ES A] FU/KKZFJRH DKS LQUOKBZ DK LEQFPR VOLJ UGHA FN;K X;K FKKA VR%] ESJK VFHKER GAS FD FU/KKZFJRH DKS LQUOKBZ VKSJ MLDS IZDJ.KKSA DKS IZLRQR DJUS DK ,D VKSJ VOLJ FN;K TKUK PKFG,A VR%] ESA ;S VIHYSA LOHD`R DJRK GWA FU/KKZFJRH DKS BL VK NSK DH IZKFIR DS NKS EKG DS VANJ FO}KU VK;DJ VK;QDR VIHY DS LE{K IZLRQR GKSU S DK FUNSZK FN;K TKRK GSA FO}KU VK;DJ VK;QDR VIHY DKS FU/KKZFJRH DKS LQ UOKBZ DK MFPR VOLJ NSUS DS I'PKR FOF/K DS VUQLKJ VIHYSA FU.KZF;R DJUK PKFG, A 5- IFJ.KKER% FU/KKZFJRH DH VIHY LKAF[;DH; MN~NS ;KSA LS LOHD`R DH TKRH GSA ;G VKNSK [KQYS U;K;KY; ESA 30-05-2016 DKS M N~?KKSF'KR FD;K X;K GSA GLRK@& MH -VH- XJKFL;K U; KF;D LNL; FNUKAD % 30-05-2016 IZFRFYFI % FU/KKZFJRH] IZR;FKHZ] VK;DJ VK;QDR VIHY ] VK;DJ VK;QDR] FOHKKXH; IZFRFUF/K] XKMZ QKBZY