M/s. Modern Enterprises, V. Income-tax Officer,

ITA 598/PUN/2009

• Counselvise Citation: [2010] 135 COUNSELVISE.COM (IT) 3111 (ITAT-PUNE)
• Duration Of Justice: 1 year(s) 6 month(s) 15 day(s)
• Appeal Type: Income Tax Appeal
• Pronouncement Date: 30-11-2010
• Appeal Filed By: Assessee
• Order Result: Allowed
• Bench Allotted: Not Allotted
• Assessment Year: misc
• Appeal Filed On: 15-05-2009
• Result in Favour of: Assessee
• Court: TRIBUNAL

Judgement Text

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